What is a Pre-Trial Examination in Quebec?
How does a pre-trial discovery work?
What are the essential elements you should know!
In this article, we will break down the notion of Pre-Trial Examination so you know all there is to know about it!
Keep reading as we have gathered exactly the information that you need!
Let’s dig into our Quebec rules of civil procedure!
Are you ready?
Let’s get started!
What Is A Pre-Trial Examination
A pre-trial examination (also referred to as just “examination” or “pre-trial discovery”) is a pre-trial procedure where the lawyers representing the parties get to ask questions from the other parties under oath.
Pre-trial examinations represent an important part of every civil lawsuit as it allows the litigants to “discover” facts and gather further factual information allowing them to support their claims or challenge the claims of the other party.
Typically, the rules governing the examinations are typically set out in the rules of civil procedure.
In Quebec, the Code of Civil Procedures provides the legal basis and procedural foundation for conducting examinations and discoveries in the context of a civil lawsuit.
What Is The Purpose of A Pre-Trial Examination
The main objective of conducting witness examinations on a pre-trial basis is to gather factual information or further documents from possible witnesses who may know something important about the case or have important documents in their possession.
Generally speaking, the objective of doing an examination is to:
- Hear the other party’s position on the matter in dispute
- Try to obtain statements from the witness allowing a party to further substantiate its position
- Try to obtain statements from the witness allowing a party to challenge the other party’s position
- Obtain documentary disclosure from a witness
Pre-trial discoveries can be held to depose a person on any fact that is relevant to the dispute and on the evidence supporting such facts.
Who Can Be Examined For Discovery
Under Article 221 of Code of Civil Procedures in Quebec, different stakeholders and classes of persons can be examined, namely:
- The representative of a company
- The agent of a company
- The employee of a company
- In civil responsibility cases, the victim of an injury or individuals involved in an injurious act or omission
- A person acting as a “prête-nom”
- A person whose rights are acquired by transfer, subrogation or other similar title
In case a party to a lawsuit may want to examine another person, it can do so provided that the party to be examined along with the other party to the lawsuit agree.
In cases where the person to be examined or other parties to the suit object, the requesting party must obtain authorization from the court.
Types of Examinations
There are essentially two types of examinations in Quebec:
- Written examination
- Oral examination
A written examination is a type of examination where a party notifies the other party of a written examination on facts relevant to the dispute.
When a notice is received, the other party must provide written responses, under oath, within the specific timeline that cannot be less than 15 days or more than 30 days.
An examination can also be done orally.
In other words, an oral pre-trial examination is when a person is called as a witness to testify on a specific date, location, and time.
Typically, the deposition of the witness is subject to the same rules as a testimony given live before a judge.
Different persons and individuals may be called for a deposition for the purpose of providing documents and performing documentary disclosures.
In this context, when a person is in possession of documents, statements, records, or other documentary evidence that may be relevant for the dispute, he or she may be called to a pre-trial examination and bring such documents.
In some cases, the witness may allude or refer to a document during his or her testimony and the deposing attorney will formally seek undertakings from the witness to provide a copy of the document in question within a mutually agreed period of time.
We refer to this as “undertakings”.
Examination For Discovery Takeaways
So what is the legal definition of Pre-Trial Examination?
If you are involved in a lawsuit and are looking for legal advice on depositions, pre-trial examinations, and discovery in general, you should consult with a civil lawyer, trial attorney, or litigation lawyer (or law firm).
This article is intended to provide you general guidance with respect to Quebec rules of civil procedure.
Now, let’s look at a summary of our findings.
Pre-Trial Examination Meaning
If you enjoyed this article on the Pre-Trial Examination, we recommend you look into the following legal terms and concepts. Enjoy!
You May Also Like Related to Pre-Trial Examinations
Examination for discovery
Hearing on merits
Subpoena ad testificandum
Subpoena duces tecum
Related to Civil Lawsuits
Alternative dispute resolution
Case management conference
Contempt of court
Motion to compel
Motion to dismiss
Notice of claim